Green Street Hooligans is a movie that depicts the lifestyle of many people all over Europe. Football based firms originated in England, but hooliganism takes place all over the world. I have seen that a group of fans out of Ohio tried to experience the thrill of hooliganism in the United States when their Major League Soccer team, the Columbus Crew, played West Ham United in 2008. Football firms are becoming a widespread phenomenon that fans everywhere are trying to associate themselves with.
Throughout this bog, I have learned that whether you are apart of a firm or not, the passion that these fans experience toward a particular team is endless. I have already stated that I love to play soccer, but I now understand why it is so important to these people. Football games and the violence surrounding it create a way to escape real life problems. Firms are about loyalty and establishing yourself as part of a devoted group of people, and this group of people becomes your family.
After conducting my research and interviews, I have discovered that hooligans are actually wealthy and have good jobs. They are able to purchase expensive clothing and attend football games every week, so why do they join firms and surround themselves with violence? The answer to this question is very simple; hooligans become involved in firms as a form of acceptance. Because as children their parents neglected them, firms give them a sense of belonging. Anthropologists study different cultures around the world, but I have learned that football is more than just a way of living to these people; attending these games, drinking beer, and fighting is how hooligans identify themselves.
Thursday, May 6, 2010
Jed & the Naughty Forty
During my research, I came across an article that was written about a man named Jed who used to be a member of the Naughty Forty. He became a member of this firm in the early nineties and gave it up after six years. Jed now dedicates time to justifying football firms, and providing truth to the image that the media creates about hooliganism. The media creates the misconception that hooligans don’t like the actual sport, but only form firms for the violence.
He first heard about the firm through a friend who was a member. The two attended a football match together, and he recalls a particular situation before entering the match, saying, “"There was a big crowd outside the away end and he turned round to me and went 'I don't like it when there's big numbers like this. Why don't you come with me, we'll go into one of the side streets, see where we could find five or ten of them on their own." This is where he immediately realized that the notions of the media were not true, and that his friend was not a member of the firm because of violence alone.
After he decided to become a member of the firm, he discovered that it was not going to be an easy task. Because trust is one of the most important things to these people, it took a lot for them to completely earn an outsider’s trust. Once Jed was considered on the inside with the Naughty Forty, he found out what true firms were all about. The trust was endless among its members, and the older members looked after the younger ones. They did whatever it took to keep them out of trouble and away from drugs.
The firm is about respect and loyalty, and the author of the article states, “the football firm offers a kind of unquestioning acceptance that is difficult to find elsewhere.” This statement is true for Jed’s situation like many other hooligans; they join to be apart of something. Unlike the media’s perspective, Jed found that they are passionate about the game. According to him, some of the matches get really bad, so you have to love the sport in order to sit through the entire game. After leaving the life of hooliganism, Jed now does performances and writes poetry about his experiences with the Naughty Forty to prove that these images are false.2002 Running with the ‘Naughty Forty.’ BBC News: World Edition, May 2.
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Interview
After interviewing a former member of a football firm, I have gotten a much better understanding as to why gangs are appealing to hooligans. The man that I interviewed is currently no longer associated with hooliganism, but wishes to remain anonymous. He is currently 48 years old and has a steady career. He was a member of the Red Army, a firm that follows Manchester United.
When I asked him what he remembers most about the guys in his firm, he said that he recalls their loyal, persistent, and reliable nature. He said that the firm was like their families. I then asked him why did they partake in violence and organize riots, and he said that at the time he would have answered it was just for the fun of it. Looking back, he says it was much more than that. The members of most gangs had money, lived in big houses, and were in schools receiving an education. The thing that many of the guys lacked was a parent who spent time with them. Parents were either divorced or had other problems, like workaholics or alcoholics. He says that the qualities that they lacked at home, they were able to find in each other. As a result, the violence and the riots were about proving your love for each other, coming back for somebody who was left behind, or standing strong next to your friends when thirty guys want to punch your face in. These are considered expressions of love for us, and that’s the reason for all the violence. He concludes by saying that he feels lucky to have so many friends that would be willing to jump in front of a train for him.
Anonymous, Tara Caney, E-Mail, Norton, MA, 20 April 2010.
When I asked him what he remembers most about the guys in his firm, he said that he recalls their loyal, persistent, and reliable nature. He said that the firm was like their families. I then asked him why did they partake in violence and organize riots, and he said that at the time he would have answered it was just for the fun of it. Looking back, he says it was much more than that. The members of most gangs had money, lived in big houses, and were in schools receiving an education. The thing that many of the guys lacked was a parent who spent time with them. Parents were either divorced or had other problems, like workaholics or alcoholics. He says that the qualities that they lacked at home, they were able to find in each other. As a result, the violence and the riots were about proving your love for each other, coming back for somebody who was left behind, or standing strong next to your friends when thirty guys want to punch your face in. These are considered expressions of love for us, and that’s the reason for all the violence. He concludes by saying that he feels lucky to have so many friends that would be willing to jump in front of a train for him.
Anonymous, Tara Caney, E-Mail, Norton, MA, 20 April 2010.
Hillsborough Tragedy
Football is a very passionate topic in many countries around the world, and has an impact on many families. The effects of violence surrounding football can be either positive or negative, but usually succeed in bringing countries together. As a soccer player, I realize how important this sport can be to some people. It is a way to identify you as an athlete, but for fans as well. Although violence is not a positive thing, outcomes resulting from the violence surrounding football can sometimes be considered beneficial to a society.
Prior to choosing my topic of hooliganism, I had heard this story before. A woman was telling me that she saw a video of innocent people getting squished and trampled over, hopelessly trying to get away. She is an avid follower of European football clubs, and remembers being disgusted by what she had witnessed. She was extremely appalled by the fact that someone decided to video tape such a horrible event, failing to try and save anyone from death when they were pleading for help. I decided to research more into the incident following her story.
On April 30th, 1989, the FA Cup semi-finals were held at Hillsborough. The match featured Canada versus Liverpool, and the fans were crazy. This disaster was not a direct result of hooliganism, but a result of the intense passion that fans all over Europe felt for the game of football. In a video one of the announcers, Des Lyonum, recalls the events as they took place, first claiming that some fans were pulling others onto the higher areas of the stadium. People were on each other’s shoulders and the place was in chaos. Because of overcrowding, fans in the back trampled over people in the front who were crushed. He goes on to say that he saw two men weeping, and when he asked them what was wrong they claimed that, “There has been dying in there, dying.” Ninety-six people were killed that day. One man claims that it took him fifteen years to tell this story without crying.
Trevor and Jenni Hicks took their teenage daughters Sarah and Victoria to this game because they were Liverpool season ticket holders. They lived in North London and traveled to a game every couple of weeks. Trevor claimed that it is one of the few things that they did as a family, and they loved it. Sarah and Victoria were both killed at Hillsborough.
Hillsborough was a tragic day for Europe because of the large number of people that it affected. Wars are taking place around the world in which so many lives are taken every day, but this particular tragedy had an impact on more than just the families that lost a loved one. It sent a wave of shock throughout most of Europe because football is not just a sport but also a part of their culture. The 21st anniversary took place on April 15th, 2010. The F.A. Cup took place at Anfield, and 10,000 seats were available. People attended the game to commemorate the tragedy at Hillsborough, and even 21 years later it was still a very emotional day for many. The Bishop of Liverpool, James Jones, states “It is our solemn responsibility to ensure that the memory of the 96, and all those whose lives were changed for ever by those terrible events, can never be forgotten” (article). The reason that this event continues to effect a large number of people are because of the meaning that the sport has to these people. This tragedy could have occurred at any stadium, and any one of these fans could have been killed.
2010 Thousands Gather in Liverpool to Mark Hillsborough. BBC News: UK, April 15.
Prior to choosing my topic of hooliganism, I had heard this story before. A woman was telling me that she saw a video of innocent people getting squished and trampled over, hopelessly trying to get away. She is an avid follower of European football clubs, and remembers being disgusted by what she had witnessed. She was extremely appalled by the fact that someone decided to video tape such a horrible event, failing to try and save anyone from death when they were pleading for help. I decided to research more into the incident following her story.On April 30th, 1989, the FA Cup semi-finals were held at Hillsborough. The match featured Canada versus Liverpool, and the fans were crazy. This disaster was not a direct result of hooliganism, but a result of the intense passion that fans all over Europe felt for the game of football. In a video one of the announcers, Des Lyonum, recalls the events as they took place, first claiming that some fans were pulling others onto the higher areas of the stadium. People were on each other’s shoulders and the place was in chaos. Because of overcrowding, fans in the back trampled over people in the front who were crushed. He goes on to say that he saw two men weeping, and when he asked them what was wrong they claimed that, “There has been dying in there, dying.” Ninety-six people were killed that day. One man claims that it took him fifteen years to tell this story without crying.
Trevor and Jenni Hicks took their teenage daughters Sarah and Victoria to this game because they were Liverpool season ticket holders. They lived in North London and traveled to a game every couple of weeks. Trevor claimed that it is one of the few things that they did as a family, and they loved it. Sarah and Victoria were both killed at Hillsborough.
Hillsborough was a tragic day for Europe because of the large number of people that it affected. Wars are taking place around the world in which so many lives are taken every day, but this particular tragedy had an impact on more than just the families that lost a loved one. It sent a wave of shock throughout most of Europe because football is not just a sport but also a part of their culture. The 21st anniversary took place on April 15th, 2010. The F.A. Cup took place at Anfield, and 10,000 seats were available. People attended the game to commemorate the tragedy at Hillsborough, and even 21 years later it was still a very emotional day for many. The Bishop of Liverpool, James Jones, states “It is our solemn responsibility to ensure that the memory of the 96, and all those whose lives were changed for ever by those terrible events, can never be forgotten” (article). The reason that this event continues to effect a large number of people are because of the meaning that the sport has to these people. This tragedy could have occurred at any stadium, and any one of these fans could have been killed.
2010 Thousands Gather in Liverpool to Mark Hillsborough. BBC News: UK, April 15.
Armstrong versus Archetti's View of Firms
An anthropologist by the name of Gary Armstrong did 14 years of participant observation with a football firm out of the United Kingdom, the Blades. This firm supported the club Sheffield United. In his effort to put an end to the myths around hooliganism,
he says, “To the outsider, violence is the raizon de’etre of a Blades gathering” (233). He claims that the level of violence surrounding hooliganism has decreased over time through increased policing at the stadiums. These gangs are a way for men to feel good about themselves, and loyalty is the basis for male hooligan culture.
Eduardo Archetti disagrees with Armstrong in his book Masculinities Football, Polo and the Tango in Argentina, claiming that the basis for hooliganism is masculinity. It is a way for men to define themselves around their manhood. He also feels that it football is a tradition to these people, tracing back hundreds of years. Every game is a way to unite fans and the entire country in order to create a sense of national pride.
Armstrong and Archetti are in disagreement about the meaning of football firms and why one might join, but they both agree that hooliganism is a cultural issue. Armstrong believes that gangs are a way for a male to transition from school to finding a career, falling in love, and settling down. Archetti believes that hooligans join firms in order to create a sense of masculine identity and pride, and football creates a way for the country to unite. When anthropologists study athletes, they look at sports as a form of creating identity. Hooligans form their identities based on the sport that they watch, the main events that surround their everyday life. Hooligan activities allow them to create notions of cohesion, uniting based on a similar love for football.
Archetti, Eduardo P.
1991 Masculinities: Football, Polo and the Tango in Argentina. New York: Berg.
Armstrong, Gary.
1998 Football Hooligans: Knowing the Score. New York: Berg.
he says, “To the outsider, violence is the raizon de’etre of a Blades gathering” (233). He claims that the level of violence surrounding hooliganism has decreased over time through increased policing at the stadiums. These gangs are a way for men to feel good about themselves, and loyalty is the basis for male hooligan culture. Eduardo Archetti disagrees with Armstrong in his book Masculinities Football, Polo and the Tango in Argentina, claiming that the basis for hooliganism is masculinity. It is a way for men to define themselves around their manhood. He also feels that it football is a tradition to these people, tracing back hundreds of years. Every game is a way to unite fans and the entire country in order to create a sense of national pride.
Armstrong and Archetti are in disagreement about the meaning of football firms and why one might join, but they both agree that hooliganism is a cultural issue. Armstrong believes that gangs are a way for a male to transition from school to finding a career, falling in love, and settling down. Archetti believes that hooligans join firms in order to create a sense of masculine identity and pride, and football creates a way for the country to unite. When anthropologists study athletes, they look at sports as a form of creating identity. Hooligans form their identities based on the sport that they watch, the main events that surround their everyday life. Hooligan activities allow them to create notions of cohesion, uniting based on a similar love for football.
Archetti, Eduardo P.
1991 Masculinities: Football, Polo and the Tango in Argentina. New York: Berg.
Armstrong, Gary.
1998 Football Hooligans: Knowing the Score. New York: Berg.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)